For investors seeking exposure to gold, mining stocks and ETFs like GDX, which holds a diversified basket of approximately 46 gold mining companies weighted by market capitalization, may seem appealing due to their leverage to the price of gold. However, while investments with higher risk are typically expected to yield higher returns over time, data reveals that mining stocks have not delivered the anticipated gains compared to physical gold. In fact, physical gold, or bullion, has provided superior returns while also offering a lower-risk investment.
Below, we compare the returns of physical gold (spot gold) against GDX and the top three gold mining companies listed on the U.S. exchange: Newmont, Agnico Eagle, and Barrick Gold, over various timeframes, highlighting a surprising performance disparity.
Gold Mining Stocks vs. Physical Gold: Top U.S.-Listed Mining Companies Comparison
| Investment | 20-Year Return | 15-Year Return | 10-Year Return | 5-Year Return |
| Newmont | 27% | 7% | 183% | 27% |
| Agnico Eagle | 530% | 67% | 305% | 53% |
| Barrick Gold | 15% | -49% | 106% | 35% |
| Average Miners | 191% | 8% | 198% | 38% |
| Spot Gold | 498% | 136% | 123% | 78% |
GDX ETF vs. Spot Gold Comparison
| Investment | 18-Year Return | 15-Year Return | 10-Year Return | 5-Year Return |
| GDX ETF | 7% | -18% | 121% | 43% |
| Spot Gold | 318% | 136% | 123% | 78% |
Key Risks of Investing in Gold Mining Stocks
Now that we have cleared the air on historical returns. Lets go through a few risks that are associated with the miners. In no particular order.
- Gold Price Volatility: Mining profits are highly dependent on gold prices, which are volatile and influenced by economic conditions, interest rates, and inflation. Price drops can sharply reduce revenue and stock value.
- Operational Risks: Mining operations face disruptions from equipment failures, labor strikes, environmental issues, and production delays, especially in remote or politically unstable areas, leading to reduced output and increased costs.
- Geopolitical and Regulatory Risks: Many mining companies operate in politically sensitive regions. Regulatory changes, taxes, and environmental regulations can impact profits, adding layers of complexity and cost.
- Cost Inflation: As resource-heavy businesses, mining companies face rising costs for energy, labor, and materials, which can erode profit margins. Currency fluctuations also add risk, as expenses may be in local currencies while revenue is in dollars.
- Reserve Depletion: Mining companies must continually invest in costly exploration to replenish reserves. If reserves aren’t replaced, production and revenue naturally decline.
- Management and Financial Risks: Mining companies can suffer from poor management decisions, project inefficiencies, or overexpansion. Additionally, high debt levels and hedging practices can limit gains, especially if gold prices rise unexpectedly.
Why Mining Risks Are Actually Good for Gold Bullion
All the risks that come with mining, like political turmoil, operational hiccups, and rising costs, can actually benefit the price of physical gold. When mining companies face disruptions or rising expenses, it often means less gold is produced, which puts upward pressure on the gold supply. With supply limited, demand for gold bullion can drive prices up, making physical gold even more valuable as an investment. Unlike mining stocks, bullion doesn’t carry these risks; instead, it simply benefits from the challenges that miners face, adding to its appeal as a steady, long-term store of value.
Conclusion: Physical Gold—The Low-Risk, High-Return Choice
In investing, higher risk typically leads to higher returns, but gold mining stocks defy this expectation. Despite their increased risks, they have delivered lower returns than physical gold over the long term. By contrast, physical gold has proven to be a better-performing, lower-risk option for investors seeking stable, long-term returns. Physical gold not only offers a hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty but also provides a level of performance that consistently outshines mining stocks.
For investors focused on wealth preservation and consistent growth, physical gold remains the gold standard. It is an investment with a proven track record of delivering both stability and superior returns, demonstrating that in this case, lower risk indeed results in greater reward.
********
